Skip to main content

Dark Matter Candidates in the Gap Model

This chapter examines which particle, symmetry and cosmological inputs each relic estimate uses.

Overview​

The heavy OO relic is a proposed field [H]. Its putative protecting symmetry fails on the density-matrix state space (T-163, withdrawn [✗], below). Production during inflation presupposes the field, its mass and a cosmological history. The QCD axion requires an additional Peccei–Quinn sector (§3). None of the estimates identifies the dark matter constituent.


1. Criteria for a Candidate​

From observations (Planck 2018): ΩDMh2=0.120±0.001\Omega_{\mathrm{DM}} h^2 = 0.120 \pm 0.001. A candidate must satisfy [D]:

  1. Electric neutrality and absence of colour charge
  2. Stability (τ≫tUniverse∼1010\tau \gg t_{\mathrm{Universe}} \sim 10^{10} yr)
  3. Correct relic density Ωh2≈0.12\Omega h^2 \approx 0.12
  4. Consistency with direct detection (XENON, LZ: σ<10−47\sigma < 10^{-47} cm2^2 for m∼102m \sim 10^2 GeV)

2. Constraints on the assumed SUSY spectra​

Theorem 8.1 [C under the listed masses, decays and production history]

The table tests the supplied SUSY scenarios. Other mass scales, symmetries and production histories give different relics.

CandidateMassProblemStatus
Neutralinom∼1013m \sim 10^{13} GeVΩh2∼1032≫0.12\Omega h^2 \sim 10^{32} \gg 0.12 (overproduction)Excluded
Gravitinom3/2∼1013m_{3/2} \sim 10^{13} GeVτ∼7×10−26\tau \sim 7 \times 10^{-26} s (unstable)Excluded
Wino/Binom∼1011m \sim 10^{11} GeVAnalogous to neutralinoExcluded

The listed choices fail the criteria in §1.

2.1 Complete Candidate Overview​

CandidateMassStabilityΩh2\Omega h^2Status
Neutralino∼1013\sim 10^{13} GeVStable (R-parity)∼1032\sim 10^{32}Excluded
Gravitino∼1013\sim 10^{13} GeVτ∼10−25\tau \sim 10^{-25} s—Excluded
Wino/Bino∼1011\sim 10^{11} GeVStable≫0.12\gg 0.12Excluded
Gap instantons∼ΛQCD\sim \Lambda_{\mathrm{QCD}}Stable (topology)—Excluded (hadronic)
G2G_2-extra bosons∼MP\sim M_PStable (G2G_2 charge)∼10−6\sim 10^{-6}Excluded (too little)
QCD axion∼3\sim 3 neVStable (U(1)PQU(1)_{\mathrm{PQ}})∼10−3\sim 10^{-3}Not realised in the Clifford content; needs (PQ) (§3, T-333(e)–(h))
Dark ALPs∼1015\sim 10^{15} GeVStableHeavyExcluded (§4)
OO-sector relicAssumed ∼1013\sim10^{13} GeVProtection open (§5.3)Scenario only (§5.4)[H]

Gap instantons are topological configurations θij(x)\theta_{ij}(x) with non-zero winding number — hadronic objects (m∼ΛQCDm \sim \Lambda_{\mathrm{QCD}}). Excluded by observations (BBN, CMB, structure formation).

G2G_2-extra bosons — 6 bosons with masses ∼MP\sim M_P. Under gravitational production Ω∼HI/MP∼10−6\Omega \sim H_I/M_P \sim 10^{-6}. Too little to be the primary DM.


3. Axion estimates under the Peccei–Quinn hypothesis​

Role of the Axion in the Gap Formalism

A QCD axion with a colour anomaly and a QCD-dominated potential could relax θˉ\bar\theta in an extended model. Strong CP

Axion conditions in the specified field content (T-333(e)–(h))

Three generations of 16\mathbf{16} with one doublet leave no colour-anomalous U(1)U(1) compatible with the quark masses. A QCD axion therefore requires a Peccei–Quinn extension (PQ) and a QCD-dominated potential. The mass formula gives ma≃2.9m_a\simeq2.9 neV when fa=2×1015f_a=2\times10^{15} GeV. If the initial angle comes entirely from inflationary fluctuations around zero, the isocurvature bound on the fraction is about 3×10−53\times10^{-5}. Confinement

3.1 Definition​

A candidate phase combination can be written in a chosen coordinate frame as

a(x):=fa⋅13∑i∈{A,S,D}∑j∈{L,E,U}cij θij(x)a(x) := f_a \cdot \frac{1}{3} \sum_{i \in \{A,S,D\}} \sum_{j \in \{L,E,U\}} c_{ij}\, \theta_{ij}(x)

An extension must supply the coefficients cijc_{ij} and a colour-anomalous axial current. The two triples of real coordinate axes in this ansatz are not invariant colour representations (registry 48a).

3.2 Decay Constant​

Theorem 9.1 [H]

The decay constant of the Gap axion:

fa=ϵ⋅MPNDW≈2×1015  GeVf_a = \frac{\epsilon \cdot M_P}{N_{\mathrm{DW}}} \approx 2 \times 10^{15}\;\text{GeV}

for ϵ∼10−3\epsilon \sim 10^{-3}, MP=2.4×1018M_P = 2.4 \times 10^{18} GeV, NDW=1N_{\mathrm{DW}} = 1 (number of domain walls for the simplest realisation).

Canonical normalisation: from the kinetic term Lkin=12mij(∂μθij)2\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{kin}} = \frac{1}{2}m_{ij}(\partial_\mu\theta_{ij})^2, where mij∼ϵ2MP2m_{ij} \sim \epsilon^2 M_P^2 in the 33-to-3ˉ\bar{3} sector, one finds fa=mij=ϵ⋅MPf_a = \sqrt{m_{ij}} = \epsilon \cdot M_P. Including RG evolution: ϵ(μGUT)∼10−3\epsilon(\mu_{\mathrm{GUT}}) \sim 10^{-3}, ϵ(μEW)∼10−2\epsilon(\mu_{\mathrm{EW}}) \sim 10^{-2}; axion physics is determined at the GUT scale.

3.3 Axion Mass​

Theorem 9.2 [C at (PQ)]

The mass is determined by QCD instantons:

ma=mumdmu+md⋅mπfπfa≈3×10−9  eV=3  neVm_a = \frac{\sqrt{m_u m_d}}{m_u + m_d} \cdot \frac{m_\pi f_\pi}{f_a} \approx 3 \times 10^{-9}\;\text{eV} = 3\;\text{neV}

An ultralight axion within the sensitivity range of the CASPEr and ABRACADABRA experiments.

3.4 Relic Density​

Theorem 9.3 [C at (PQ)]

From the vacuum misalignment mechanism:

Ωah2≈0.12×(fa1012  GeV)7/6×(θiπ)2≈10−3\Omega_a h^2 \approx 0.12 \times \left(\frac{f_a}{10^{12}\;\text{GeV}}\right)^{7/6} \times \left(\frac{\theta_i}{\pi}\right)^2 \approx 10^{-3}

For θi∼HI/(2πfa)<3.7×10−3\theta_i \sim H_I/(2\pi f_a) < 3.7 \times 10^{-3} (from the Planck bound r<0.036r < 0.036):

Ωah2≈0.12×7100×1.39×10−6≈1.2×10−3\Omega_a h^2 \approx 0.12 \times 7100 \times 1.39 \times 10^{-6} \approx 1.2 \times 10^{-3}

The quoted 1%1\% abundance cannot be assigned to the stated fluctuation-only initial condition. With a QCD axion added, the isocurvature analysis in T-333(e)–(h) instead caps its fraction near 3×10−53\times10^{-5} in that scenario.

3.5 Full Axion Spectrum from (S1)21(S^1)^{21}​

Compactification on the torus (S1)21(S^1)^{21} generates the full spectrum of axion-like particles (ALPs). Of the 21 compact phases θij\theta_{ij}, the mass spectrum is determined by the sectoral structure of the Gap vacuum:

Hypothesis [H]

Mass spectrum of the multi-axion system from (S1)21(S^1)^{21}:

SectorNumber of modesMass scaleMass-generation mechanism
33-to-3ˉ\bar{3}: QCD axion1ma∼3m_a \sim 3 neVQCD instantons
33-to-3ˉ\bar{3}: gluonic8m∼ΛQCD∼1m \sim \Lambda_{\mathrm{QCD}} \sim 1 GeVConfinement
33-to-33: dark ALPs3m∼109m \sim 10^{9}–101510^{15} GeVHessian of VGapV_{\mathrm{Gap}}
3ˉ\bar{3}-to-3ˉ\bar{3}: electroweak ALPs3m∼vEWm \sim v_{\mathrm{EW}}–101510^{15} GeVEWSB ++ VGapV_{\mathrm{Gap}}
OO-sector6m∼MPm \sim M_PGap ∼1\sim 1 (hard modes)

All 21 phases acquire mass from the potentials V3V_3 or V2V_2 — there are no flat directions. This is a fundamental distinction from models with tuned potentials: Gap theory does not naturally predict ultralight axions (fuzzy DM, m∼10−22m \sim 10^{-22} eV). [H]


4. Hypothetical axion-like fields​

The table groups coordinates in a chosen frame. Assigning particles, charges and masses to these coordinates is an additional hypothesis.

SectorPhasesGapModes
33-to-3ˉ\bar{3} ({A,S,D}×{L,E,U}\{A,S,D\} \times \{L,E,U\})9→0\to 01 QCD axion + 8 gluonic (m∼ΛQCDm \sim \Lambda_{\mathrm{QCD}})
33-to-33 ({A,S,D}×{A,S,D}\{A,S,D\} \times \{A,S,D\}, i<ji<j)3∼ϵspace\sim \epsilon_{\mathrm{space}}3 dark ALPs
3ˉ\bar{3}-to-3ˉ\bar{3} ({L,E,U}×{L,E,U}\{L,E,U\} \times \{L,E,U\})3∼ϵEW\sim \epsilon_{\mathrm{EW}}3 electroweak ALPs (massive after EWSB)
OO-sector6∼1\sim 16 heavy modes (m∼MPm \sim M_P)

Potential DM candidates are the 3 dark ALPs from the 33-to-33 sector: pairs (A,S)(A,S), (A,D)(A,D), (S,D)(S,D).

Hypothesis [H]

The masses of the dark ALPs are determined by the Hessian of VGapV_{\mathrm{Gap}} in the vacuum:

mALP∼λ3 ϵ μphys∼1015  GeVm_{\mathrm{ALP}} \sim \sqrt{\lambda_3}\,\epsilon\,\mu_{\mathrm{phys}} \sim 10^{15}\;\text{GeV}

This is of GUT order — too heavy for standard DM mechanisms. With additional suppression of λ3\lambda_3 from partial SUSY preservation in the 33-to-33 sector (Gap ∼ϵspace∼10−3\sim \epsilon_{\mathrm{space}} \sim 10^{-3}): mALP∼109m_{\mathrm{ALP}} \sim 10^{9} GeV — still heavy, but accessible to gravitational production (§5).

There are no flat directions: all 21 phases acquire mass from V3V_3 or V2V_2. Gap theory does not naturally predict ultralight axions (fuzzy DM).

Open Direction: Collective Enhancement [H]

Multi-axion cosmology from (S1)21(S^1)^{21} is an open question of medium priority. Is collective enhancement of the relic density possible when several ALP fields are simultaneously present? This may modify the estimate of Ωah2\Omega_a h^2 for the subdominant axion sector.


5. OO-Sector Relic (Wimpzilla)​

5.1 OO-Sector Dark Matter​

The proposed scenario adds a weakly coupled particle of mass mX∼1013m_X\sim10^{13} GeV. A large matrix opacity carries no units of mass. The verified transport model starts from a specified moving register and link variables. Frame covariance of its motion holds for its chosen group and representation. Identifying a physical dark particle requires an independent spectrum. Network results

5.2 Gravitational Production during Inflation​

The Chung–Kolb–Riotto (CKR, 1998) mechanism predicts a particle number density of mass mm in de Sitter space with Hubble parameter HIH_I:

n∼HI3⋅e−2πm/HIfor m>HIn \sim H_I^3 \cdot e^{-2\pi m / H_I} \quad \text{for } m > H_I

For mX/HI≫1m_X/H_I\gg1 the exponential suppresses production in this approximation. Near mX=HIm_X=H_I a quantitative abundance needs the field equation and the inflation-to-reheating transition.

Theorem 11.1 [H, illustrative abundance model]

The parameterization used below is

ΩXh2≈0.1×(mX1013  GeV)3/2×(HI1013  GeV)∼0.1–0.4\Omega_X h^2 \approx 0.1 \times \left(\frac{m_X}{10^{13}\;\text{GeV}}\right)^{3/2} \times \left(\frac{H_I}{10^{13}\;\text{GeV}}\right) \sim 0.1\text{--}0.4

for mX=m3/2∼1013m_X = m_{3/2} \sim 10^{13} GeV, HI∼4×1013H_I \sim 4 \times 10^{13} GeV.

The range uses chosen masses and Hubble rates. Gravitational production also depends on the inflationary transition, subsequent dilution and survival to the present. The group stabilizer and a choice of superpotential do not fix those inputs.

5.3 OO-Parity​

Write PO=(−1)ΔNOP_O=(-1)^{\Delta N_O} for a model with an integer excitation count. The definition assigns a sign. Conservation would require a symmetry of all allowed transitions.

Theorem 11.2 (T-163) — partial conjugation fails [✗]​

The stabilizer of the chosen octonionic axis is SU(3)\mathrm{SU}(3) [T]. The proposed extra involution conjugates only the entries touching OO, leaving the other entries unchanged. Take the pure state ψ=(1,1,i)/3\psi=(1,1,i)/\sqrt3 on axes (O,a,b)(O,a,b), padded by zeros on the remaining axes. On its support, ρ=ψψ†\rho=\psi\psi^\dagger and its proposed image are

ρ=13(11−i11−iii1),σ(ρ)=13(11i11−i−ii1).\rho=\frac13\begin{pmatrix}1&1&-i\\1&1&-i\\i&i&1\end{pmatrix}, \qquad \sigma(\rho)=\frac13\begin{pmatrix}1&1&i\\1&1&-i\\-i&i&1\end{pmatrix}.

The displayed principal minor of the image is −4/27-4/27. Hence the image fails positivity and the map cannot act as a symmetry on density matrices. Global conjugation is a different map. A finite barrier also permits tunnelling in principle. A stable relic would need a state-preserving symmetry and dynamics conserving its charge, or an independently computed lifetime [H].

5.4 Details of CKR Production of the OO-Relic​

The Chung–Kolb–Riotto (CKR) mechanism describes non-thermal production of heavy particles through rapid expansion of de Sitter space during inflation. For OO-sector configurations the process proceeds in three stages:

Theorem 11.1a [C for the specified production history]. If the species survives, its number density scales as a−3a^{-3} after production with conserved comoving number. For production at a∗a_* this gives

ΩXh2=h2mXnX(a∗)ρc,0(a∗a0)3.\Omega_X h^2 = \frac{h^2m_X n_X(a_*)}{\rho_{c,0}}\left(\frac{a_*}{a_0}\right)^3.

The mass, production rate and dilution enter separately. In natural units HI3H_I^3 has units of energy cubed. Substitution of mX=1013m_X=10^{13} GeV and HI=4×1013H_I=4\times10^{13} GeV in the illustrative §5.2 formula gives 0.40.4. Comparing that output to 0.120±0.0010.120\pm0.001 cannot establish a relic species or select its mass.

5.5 Interaction Cross Section of the OO-Relic​

11.3. Dimensional check. In natural units GN2mX2mN2G_N^2m_X^2m_N^2 is dimensionless. It cannot supply the stated area in cm2\mathrm{cm}^2. A scattering calculation needs a field interaction, incident kinematics, momentum-transfer range and a detector response for the proposed mass. The cross section is open.

warning
Annihilation Cross Section for OO-Relic Pairs [H]

For pairs of OO-quanta (ΔNO=2\Delta N_O = 2, PO=+1P_O = +1) annihilation is possible:

σannv∼mX2MP4∼10−46  GeV−2\sigma_{\mathrm{ann}} v \sim \frac{m_X^2}{M_P^4} \sim 10^{-46}\;\text{GeV}^{-2}

Annihilation OOˉ→O\bar{O} \to SM particles with energy E∼mX∼1013E \sim m_X \sim 10^{13} GeV may produce ultra-high-energy cosmic rays (UHECR, E>1020E > 10^{20} eV) — a potentially observable signal.

5.6 Relic Density Budget​

Conditional scenarios

The entries assume particle content and production histories.

ComponentMassΩh2\Omega h^2Fraction of DMMechanism
OO relicAssumed ∼1013\sim10^{13} GeV§5.2 estimateUndeterminedGravitational production
QCD axion (only under (PQ), T-333(e)–(h))∼3\sim 3 neV≲4×10−6\lesssim 4 \times 10^{-6} (isocurvature)≲3×10−5\lesssim 3\times10^{-5}Vacuum misalignment
Dark ALPs∼109\sim 10^{9}–101510^{15} GeVnegligible≪1%\ll 1\%Gravitational (suppressed)
G2G_2-extra bosons∼MP\sim M_P∼10−6\sim 10^{-6}≪1%\ll 1\%Gravitational (exponentially suppressed)

The relative abundances are undetermined.


6. Conditions for a heavy relic​

ParameterValueSource
MassAssumed ∼1013\sim10^{13} GeV§5.1
Production mechanismGravitational (inflation, CKR)§5.4 above
ΩXh2\Omega_X h^2Scenario estimate at chosen mX,HIm_X,H_I§5.4
StabilityOpen after the T-163 counterexample§5.3
Direct detectionCross section undetermined§5.5
Indirect signaturesUHECR (E>1020E > 10^{20} eV) from annihilationTestable

7. Fano Correlation Length ξF\xi_F​

The Fano correlation length ξF\xi_F is the scale over which Fano correlations in the Gap vacuum decay. It is connected to the spatial distribution of dark matter through the structure of the Gap vacuum.

7.1 Definition​

CFano(r):=⟨Fijk(0)⋅Fijk(r)⟩vac∼e−r/ξFC_{\mathrm{Fano}}(r) := \langle F_{ijk}(0) \cdot F_{ijk}(r) \rangle_{\mathrm{vac}} \sim e^{-r/\xi_F}

where Fijk(x)=εijkFano⋅Gap(i,j,x)⋅Gap(j,k,x)⋅Gap(i,k,x)F_{ijk}(x) = \varepsilon_{ijk}^{\mathrm{Fano}} \cdot \mathrm{Gap}(i,j,x) \cdot \mathrm{Gap}(j,k,x) \cdot \mathrm{Gap}(i,k,x) is the local Fano function.

7.2 RG Evolution​

Theorem 9.4 [T]

The Fano correlation length satisfies the RG equation:

dln⁡ξFdln⁡μ=−1+ηF,ηF=542≈0.119\frac{d \ln \xi_F}{d \ln \mu} = -1 + \eta_F, \quad \eta_F = \frac{5}{42} \approx 0.119

where ηF\eta_F is the anomalous dimension of the Fano operator. Solution:

ξF(μ)=ℓPlanck⋅(MPlanckμ)37/42\xi_F(\mu) = \ell_{\mathrm{Planck}} \cdot \left(\frac{M_{\mathrm{Planck}}}{\mu}\right)^{37/42}

7.3 Quantitative Prediction​

At the Hubble scale (μ∼H0∼10−33\mu \sim H_0 \sim 10^{-33} eV):

ξF(H0)=ℓPlanck⋅(1028  eV10−33  eV)37/42=10−35  m⋅1053.7≈5×1018  m∼160  pc\xi_F(H_0) = \ell_{\mathrm{Planck}} \cdot \left(\frac{10^{28}\;\text{eV}}{10^{-33}\;\text{eV}}\right)^{37/42} = 10^{-35}\;\text{m} \cdot 10^{53.7} \approx 5 \times 10^{18}\;\text{m} \sim 160\;\text{pc}
Note: Physical Meaning [I]

ξF∼160\xi_F \sim 160 pc is a scale comparable to the size of small molecular clouds. This defines the region within which Gap configurations are correlated through the Fano structure. Number of uncorrelated Fano modes in the observable Universe:

NF=(RHξF)3=(4.4×1026  m5×1018  m)3≈6.8×1023N_F = \left(\frac{R_H}{\xi_F}\right)^3 = \left(\frac{4.4 \times 10^{26}\;\text{m}}{5 \times 10^{18}\;\text{m}}\right)^3 \approx 6.8 \times 10^{23}
Caveat: Two Scales [I]

ℓPlanck\ell_{\mathrm{Planck}} is the UV cutoff (lattice spacing), ξF\xi_F is the IR correlation. These are different physical scales. The number of degrees of freedom NDOF=V/ℓP3N_{\mathrm{DOF}} = V/\ell_P^3 should not be confused with the number of Fano modes NF=(RH/ξF)3∼1024N_F = (R_H/\xi_F)^3 \sim 10^{24}.


8. Conditional estimates and observables​

The entries use the candidate fields, masses, cosmological history and coupling scales specified in §§2–7. For example, the value of the axion mass requires (PQ), and a heavy relic requires an independent stability mechanism.

#PredictionValueExperiment
P1ma∼3m_a \sim 3 neV (only under (PQ), T-333(e)–(h))2.85×10−92.85 \times 10^{-9} eVCASPEr, ABRACADABRA
P2fa∼2×1015f_a \sim 2 \times 10^{15} GeVFrom ϵ⋅MP\epsilon \cdot M_PAxion-photon conversion
P3Ωa/ΩDM∼10−2\Omega_a / \Omega_{\mathrm{DM}} \sim 10^{-2} — excluded by isocurvature (T-333(e)–(h))≲3×10−5\lesssim 3\times10^{-5} under (PQ)Cosmological constraints
P4mDM∼1013m_{\mathrm{DM}} \sim 10^{13} GeVWimpzillaUHECR anomalies
P5Direct search for a heavy relicNo derived cross section at mX∼1013m_X\sim10^{13} GeVXENON, LZ
P6ξF∼160\xi_F \sim 160 pcFano correlation lengthLarge-scale structure

9. Connection to Other Sections​

TopicPageConnection
Cosmological ConstantCosmological ConstantVacuum structure, OO-sector and ξF\xi_F in the Λ\Lambda budget
Einstein equationsEinstein equationsConditional matter coupling in a metric theory
G2G_2-StructureG2G_2-StructureFano plane and sectoral decomposition
Berry phaseBerry phaseHomotopy of specified field maps
Fano Selection RuleFano Selection RulesFano correlations and ξF\xi_F
ConfinementConfinement from GapGap →0\to 0 in the 33-to-3ˉ\bar{3} sector; QCD axion

Related documents: