Gap Lagrangian models: a selected action and its scope
A phase action and a GKSL generator each require a domain, coefficients and an observation model. Relating their solutions requires a derivation from shared dynamics.
1. Coordinates and constraints
In a fixed frame, for . A local phase chart needs ; estimation stability needs an amplitude floor. Seven populations have six independent coordinates;21complex coherences have42real coordinates. Phases alone do not determine a state. Varying phases at fixed amplitudes can violate positivity, so the admissible domain must be checked.
Diagonal rephasing sends to . Triangle holonomy is invariant under this operation, but selected real-G2-frame observables need not share that gauge symmetry. G2 does not generally act on a fixed-amplitude phase torus as a closed state domain.
2. Explicit model ansatz
Select a local phase domain, a constant symmetric positive definite matrix , smooth potential and action
has units consistent with action and the selected time; coefficients do not follow from seven axes. The potential and its symmetries are separate inputs. Select a force with symmetric . Lagrange–d’Alembert gives
This follows exactly from the stated action and forces, not from arbitrary density evolution.
Choose a kinetic term, potential and dissipative dynamics. A positive mass matrix and well-defined generator are independent requirements. Additional Lindblad channels are admissible.
3. What a matrix ODE supplies
For specified where ,
Differentiate to obtain these identities. They give first-order dynamics. A second-order inertial equation needs velocity state or an independent closure; relabeling a dephasing rate as friction does not create it. At zero amplitude the phase and division are undefined.
4. Keldysh and the physical bridge
Closed-time-path methods are tools for a specified microscopic model. Deriving an effective action needs degrees of freedom, initial state, reservoir interaction, eliminated variables and controlled approximations. The method itself does not select , a potential or UHM’s six terms. See the primary review Sieberer–Buchhold–Diehl.
The trace of the product of two Hermitian matrices is real. A nonzero Berry term therefore needs data such as an eigenline and its connection. Exact equivalence of the phase action and the generator would require matching trajectories and observables.
5. Symmetries and interpretation
If specified respect a group, apply Noether’s theorem to the conservative part and compute charge changes from . Equal projector dimensions do not supply intertwiners with irreducible G2 representations. An odd term of a selected potential does not prove universal PT breaking: transformation of the state and all parameters must be specified.
Habit, qualia and the direction of experienced time are interpretations [I]. Phase coordinates, physical energy units and experimental readout need independent calibration.
See variational derivation, Gap, Gap thermodynamics and Noether charges.