Readout and the proposed functor F
The proposed physical-to-experiential bridge requires a chosen state readout and an interpretation. It is not uniquely determined by the symmetry group of its codomain. The former universal T-42a/T-123 uniqueness claim is withdrawn [✗]; the replacement theorem establishes unitary/ comparison only under explicit reversible-identification assumptions (RI).
What a functor specifies
A functor assigns objects and arrows and preserves identities and composition:
Specifying only on states does not supply its action on processes. Declaring an experiential interpretation does not prove either functoriality or uniqueness.
Object readout
For choose , with a specified quality/configuration space [D/I]. The spectral data are basis-independent. Eigenvectors in a degenerate eigenspace are not unique. A ray list requires a gauge choice or a quotient; it is not a continuous global spectral coordinate system.
In native , the axis has rank one: , whose normalisation is just . The notation is meaningful only for a declared tensor factor, not for deleting six basis directions. An extended experiential register and its readout are additional model input. Identifying its rays or eigenvalues with experienced qualities or intensities remains [I/H].
Descent of arrows
For a surjective , a channel induces an actual map iff it preserves the readout's equivalence relation:
Then is well-defined and unique. These channels are closed under composition, and , . This defines a functor on the declared restricted category [T]. If is a quotient map, continuity of also makes continuous. Full proof.
Reading only fails descent for general channels: swapping axes reveals different weights in states with the same weight. Thus an arbitrary channel has no automatic restricted map on experience. Unspecified natural transformations or higher associators do not repair this obstruction.
Faithfulness and identification
Faithfulness means injection on every hom-set, not on objects. Bijective gives a faithful conjugation assignment on represented processes, but does not identify the represented category with experience. Covariance can hold for a constant encoder into a stationary state; forward-flow uniqueness does not prove encoder injectivity.
Under RI, comparison of two complete encoders and its inverse extend to CPTP maps; the comparison is unitary conjugation. Requiring a chosen unitary lift to preserve a specified positive octonionic three-form restricts it to . If a fixed frame is retained, its common stabilizer further restricts the comparison. These are conditional statements about declared encodings, not a canonical phenomenal translator.
Geometry and phenomenal interpretation
For a chosen register the Fubini–Study metric on is
for unit representatives. The enriched Yoneda theorem proves precise relational and finite-probe statements inside that quality model. It does not prove that those rays are conscious experiences or that exists on every quantum process.
A continuous readout between specified spaces induces a geometric morphism between their open-cover sheaf topoi. This sheaf-level construction is different from the process functor and has no automatic physical/phenomenal interpretation. AI encodings and fitted CPTP process approximations require the measurement protocol; ordinary Jacobian linearization does not imply complete positivity or trace preservation.
Current status
The descent criterion and restricted functoriality are [T]. The state readout, experimental calibration and phenomenal bridge are [D/H/I]. Universal uniqueness, unconditional faithfulness, automatic higher-category completion and closure of the explanatory gap are withdrawn [✗]. Canonical details: categorical formalism, representation/tomography, mathematical kernel.
Historical section addresses
The corrected scope of statements at these addresses is given above.