Skip to main content

Structure: the Geometry of Quality Space

Why structure is the strongest channel

A calibration fixes constants; any theory can be fitted to a single quality. A structure — the pattern of relations among many qualities, or among the components of Γ\Gamma — can be fitted only if it has the shape the theory committed to before the data were seen. UHM commits in advance to complex projective geometry for quality, seven axes and seven Fano lines for Γ\Gamma, a window and two bands for a living state. Each commitment forbids something measurable. This page lists the commitments with their statuses, the methods that test them, and the results that would count for and against. It reports no data.

What a structural test can and cannot show​

  • Geometry and the operational gate. Rays of an orthonormal eigenbasis are orthogonal, so their pairwise Fubini–Study distances alone do not reproduce a general similarity geometry. A chosen quality-ray map requires its own calibration. Keeping eigenrays fixed while changing eigenvalues can change purity and canonical RR; phase Gap likewise does not determine Cap2\mathrm{Cap}_2. Being in 2/7<P≤3/72/7<P\le3/7 does not by itself meet the integration/differentiation conditions. Cross-person or model alignment is evidence about the declared structure, not a consciousness certificate.
  • Phenomenal bridge [I/H]. A preregistered structural match can support a specified map between experience reports and states; it does not alone prove identity. Revised T-214 supplies no universal no-go against an internal bridge: an arbitrary internal map is not a weakly point-surjective Lawvere evaluator. An empirical mismatch tests the chosen bridge and reconstruction assumptions, not that withdrawn theorem.
  • It needs calibration for its metric form. Without the map ff from perceived dissimilarity to dFSd_{\mathrm{FS}} (calibration, K3) every metric test below is ordinal.

The invariants​

Each row gives what UHM asserts, the status of the assertion, and where it is proved or stated. "Math" is the status of the statement about Γ\Gamma; "reading" is the status of its reading as a statement about experience.

#InvariantMathReadingSource
S1Choose a quality-ray map into CPn−1\mathbb{CP}^{n-1} with FS distance; on this separated metric space enriched Yoneda is isometric and isomorphic points coincide[D] for the chosen space; [T] for the conditional metric resultsIdentification with experience [I/H]enriched Yoneda
S2For a nondegenerate native spectrum, six eigenvalues and a 42-dimensional unitary orbit describe distinct data; degeneracies reduce orbit dimension[T] (T-300)Reading these as intensity and quality is [I/H]qualia structure
S3The chosen native representation has seven axes, 21 complex pairs and 48 real coordinates; its traceless operator representation splits as 27⊕14⊕727\oplus14\oplus7[T] for the representation (T-301); no phenomenal-completeness theoremNames of channels [I]; extensions and histories require additional datataxonomy, decoder
S4Supported cycle phases are diagonal-rephasing invariants; on full K7K_7 support the seven Fano triangles span seven of 15 independent cycles[T] (T-301)Reading any of these as quality is [I/H]decoder
S5Seven line readouts group the 21 edges; the isotropic Fano channel scales every off-diagonal pair equally and preserves supported phases[T] for incidence and this channelPreferential empirical block transparency needs a separate hypothesisFano channel
S6Intra-line Gap below inter-line Gap; testable as triple holonomy on 7 lines against 28 non-lines[H] (F-Gap-1)—F-Gap-1
S7Under eij=sisje_{ij}=s_i s_j, si∈{±1}s_i\in\{\pm1\}, a line product is +1+1; a single edge flip is detected but not located within that line[T] under the vertex-sign model (T-306)Arbitrary PSD coherences need not obey this sign modelwhat a line checks
S8Purity/reflection cuts are equivalent to 2/7<P≤3/72/7<P\le3/7; Φ≥1\Phi\ge1 and differentiation need separate checks[T under chosen cuts]; full four-way independence withdrawnCap2\mathrm{Cap}_2 is operational [D], phenomenal reading [I/H]revised window
S9The chosen native purity/reflection/integration cuts imply s1∈[1/7,3/14]s_1\in[1/7,3/14], s2∈[1/7,2/7]s_2\in[1/7,2/7]; the bands alone do not establish L2[T] for these necessary inequalities (T-321, T-323)Physical or phenomenal interpretation requires the declared bridgeF-Band
S10For constant γ≥0\gamma\ge0 and the specified Fano generator γ(PFano−id)\gamma(\mathcal P_{\rm Fano}-\mathrm{id}), moduli scale as e−2γt/3e^{-2\gamma t/3} and supported cycle angles stay fixed; other generators need their own analysis[T] for this dynamics and supportFading of experience remains [H] under a calibrated readouthow qualia die
S11At fixed populations/moduli, phase affects admissibility through PSD; selected equal-twist families reported a line angle near 0.63870.6387 rad at Φ=1\Phi=1Family-specific report; no universal phase/integration opposition follows (T-307)Interpretation [I/H]scope and counterexamples
S12Emotional space is 30-dimensional; valence is sign(dP/dτ)\mathrm{sign}(dP/d\tau)[T] (T-147); valence [C] (C.1)names of emotions [I]emotional taxonomy
S13Number of independent slow components in fMRI lies in [6,12][6, 12][H] (F-ISF)—F-ISF

Dimension of quality space. Declare the register and normalized readout before choosing n=dim⁡HEn=\dim\mathcal H_E. A native E-axis has rank one; a seven-dimensional conditional clock block is one optional construction in a specified 7×67\times6 model, not a factor recovered uniquely from Γ\Gamma. Similarity data may constrain a chosen ray-model dimension, but cannot by themselves establish that the fitted rays are eigenvectors or an ontological experiential register (realization contract).

What the geometry forbids​

A commitment is worth as much as what it excludes. From the invariants above, UHM forbids:

  1. Metric violations. For a calibrated FS model, require d(a,c)≤d(a,b)+d(b,c)+τd(a,c)\le d(a,b)+d(b,c)+\tau for all ordered triples, with uncertainty and tolerance τ\tau fixed by the protocol. The historical 0.150.15-radian tolerance is a design choice, not a theorem. Requiring the absolute triangle slack to be small would wrongly force near-collinearity. Distances lie in [0,π/2][0,\pi/2].
  2. Unrealisable matrices. A finite dissimilarity matrix (dij)(d_{ij}) is realised by rays of CPn−1\mathbb{CP}^{n-1} if and only if, for some phases θij=−θji\theta_{ij} = -\theta_{ji}, the Hermitian matrix Gij=cos⁡(dij) eiθijG_{ij} = \cos(d_{ij})\,e^{i\theta_{ij}}, Gii=1G_{ii} = 1, is positive semidefinite of rank at most nn (item 7 of the enriched Yoneda theorem [T]). In particular at most nn qualities can be pairwise at the maximal distance π/2\pi/2.
  3. Full-space covering radius. For n>1n>1 and 0<δ≤π/20<\delta\le\pi/2, a δ\delta-cover of all CPn−1\mathbb{CP}^{n-1} needs at least sin⁡−2(n−1)δ\sin^{-2(n-1)}\delta probes. Thus 93 probes cannot have global covering radius below arcsin⁡(1/93)≈0.104\arcsin(1/\sqrt{93})\approx0.104 rad on CP1\mathbb{CP}^1. This is not a universal lower bound on statistical estimation precision or on resolution of a restricted stimulus family; the finite-probe theorem gives an error bound for its stated covering design.
  4. A conscious state outside the bands. A system that independent evidence in DnatD_{\mathrm{nat}} calls conscious, whose reconstructed Γ^\hat\Gamma lies outside the window or outside F-Band, falsifies the reconstruction; a state meeting all four criteria with s1s_1 or s2s_2 outside its band falsifies the algebra (F-Band; zero counterexamples over 20 00020\,000 states per band so far).
  5. Drift while fading [H]. The Fano-only law fixes supported cycle angles while reducing their carriers. Predicting stable psychological qualities additionally requires a declared register/readout and its dynamics. It is that compound empirical hypothesis, not a consequence of coherence damping alone, which a drift test can challenge.

Methods​

Similarity geometry: MDS and representational similarity analysis​

Collect full pairwise dissimilarity matrices within one modality. Predeclare the stimulus-to-ray map and normalized representatives, then compare calibrated dissimilarities with their FS distances. Arbitrarily selected eigenvectors at degeneracy are not observations; the rays of an orthonormal eigenbasis are mutually orthogonal and cannot alone encode a nontrivial similarity matrix. If the readout yields mixed register states, predeclare a full-state metric such as Bures instead of silently treating them as rays. The calibration protocol supplies measurement error, cross-validation and chosen thresholds; its numerical tolerances are not consequences of FS geometry.

The Tsuchiya paradigm: enriched categories and unsupervised alignment​

Tsuchiya, Phillips and Saigo (2022) model a declared quality space using dissimilarities; Gromov–Wasserstein methods compare specified metric-measure structures without shared labels. UHM can test the additional FS-ray hypothesis against alternatives. Enriched isomorphic points coincide within one separated metric space; an isometry between two spaces is not pointwise identity or proof of shared experience. Under the appropriate metric-measure hypotheses, zero Gromov–Wasserstein distance identifies structures up to measure-preserving isometry of their supports. Sampling, calibration and the phenomenal bridge remain separate (conditional metric result; research precedent).

Realisability and the rank of quality space — proposed here [Pr]​

For a calibrated matrix, search over phases for the smallest rank n∗n^* of a positive semidefinite GG realising it within measurement error. Two predictions follow [H]: (a) n∗n^* exists — the matrix is realisable at all; (b) within one modality n∗n^* stabilises as stimuli are added, rather than growing with the stimulus count. A competing geometry (real Euclidean, hyperbolic) is compared by cross-validated fit at equal parameter count; a systematically better fit of a non-projective geometry counts against S1.

Topological analysis​

Persistent homology of the similarity structure reports the topology of the sampled set of qualities — the hue circle, for instance, is one loop. It does not see the ambient space: a circle embeds in CP1\mathbb{CP}^1 as well as in the plane. Topology therefore tests S1 only through what the ambient geometry constrains — bounded diameter, the maximal-distance count, realisability — and is used here to choose stimulus sets that cover a manifold without holes in the probe cover (item 3 above).

Structure of Γ\Gamma itself​

  • Seven axes and the Fano blocks in self-report: confirmatory factor analysis of the 28-item audit, testing whether the 7-triad block structure fits better than random tripartitions (Console V0-VAL, a self-report analogue of F-Gap-2).
  • Seven axes in neural data: the number of independent slow components in fMRI (F-ISF [H]), and the seven-component stress tensor (experiment IV.1).
  • Fano holonomy: compare supported ∣Hp∣\lvert H_p\rvert on seven lines with the 28 non-line triangles using independently calibrated signed phases and declared uncertainty. The historical 180-state construction reported +0.03±0.39+0.03\pm0.39 rad; this descriptive result is not physical validation. The Fano channel preserves every supported cycle angle, including non-line cycles, so that channel alone cannot create a line/non-line phase separation. Such separation is a separate hypothesis about the source and full dynamics (current empirical status).
  • Window and bands: P^\hat P, Φ^\hat\Phi, R^\hat R, s1s_1, s2s_2 across sleep–wake and anaesthesia with a frozen πbio\pi_{\mathrm{bio}} (calibration, K1–K2). On the uniform diagonal the window is exactly Φ∈(1,2]\Phi \in (1, 2], R∈[1/3,1/2)R \in [1/3, 1/2), C∈(1/2,2/3]C \in (1/2, 2/3] (Step 5 [T]) — three readouts that must move together.
  • Fading [Pr]: collect repeated similarity judgements on a fixed stimulus set, with predeclared calibration and an independently justified dynamical/readout model. Native coherence damping alone predicts neither register eigenvalues nor a psychological similarity order. Stable similarity under decreasing intensity tests the additional bridge; drift challenges that empirical model on its admitted domain, not the conditional phase-preservation identity.

Confirmation and refutation​

InvariantWould confirmWould refute
S1 geometryCalibrated matrices realisable at a stable n∗n^*; projective geometry fits better than Euclidean at equal parameters; cross-subject alignment near-isometricMetric violations beyond tolerance; more pairwise-maximal qualities than n∗n^*; unrealisable matrices after calibration
S2 intensity/qualityIsospectral states differ in quality, not intensity; context changes quality at fixed ρE\rho_EIdentical full invariants, distinguishable experience (refutation criterion)
S3 seven axes7-triad structure beats random tripartitions; NISF∈[6,12]N_{\mathrm{ISF}} \in [6, 12]Block structure no better than random; NISFN_{\mathrm{ISF}} systematically outside [6,12][6, 12]
S4–S6 FanoA preregistered source/dynamics hypothesis predicts a reproducible line/non-line differenceFailure of that empirical hypothesis; not cycle invariance, which predicts no separation from Fano damping alone
S8–S9 window and bandsWake inside, N3 below, both exits as predicted; conscious states inside F-BandAny of the falsifiers of calibration; a conscious state outside F-Band
S10 fadingUnder the declared dynamical/readout bridge, intensity falls while similarity order holdsDrift contradicts that bridge on its admitted domain; not phase preservation under the specified Fano-only law

A single refutation acts at the status of the claim it hits: against a [T] row it means an error in the proof or in the bridge to data (the experimental protocol's structural level), against an [H] row it removes the hypothesis, against an [I] reading it removes the support that reading had.

Next: Engineering → · Back: Calibration